Why Strict Pragma is preferred over Floating.

In Solidity, a pragma is a directive that provides instructions to the compiler regarding how to process the source code. Pragma Solidity is shorthand for “Pragmatic Information for Solidity.” and It specifies the compiler version to be used to compile a contract. While the pragma version doesn't directly influence the compiler's version, it prompts the compiler to verify compatibility, generating an error if a mismatch occurs. This verification process is crucial because even minor differences in compiler versions can impact the behavior of a contract.

How Does Pragma Work in Solidity

The Solidity pragma is specific to each source file, requiring every Solidity file to define this directive to inform the compiler of the Solidity version used in the code. This includes imported libraries as well. There are different methods to define the pragma version. One option is to use a floating pragma, which indicates a range of acceptable compiler versions for compilation. Alternatively, a strict pragma can be employed, fixing the compiler version explicitly.

A floating pragma is a pragma statement that doesn't pinpoint a precise compiler version but instead delineates a range of compiler versions acceptable for compilation. I.e. pragma solidity ^0.8.0;

pragma solidity 0.8.20; is a strict pragma.

pragma solidity ^0.8.20; is a floating pragma.

pragma solidity >=0.6.0 <0.8.20 is a range pragma.

The ^ symbol in Example 2 indicates that the code should be compiled using a compiler version compatible with 0.8.20 and above but below 0.9.0 (if it exists).

Sticking to a single compiler version is commonly regarded as the best approach. Employing a floating pragma could lead to inadvertent deployment of contracts with outdated or problematic compiler versions, potentially introducing bugs and compromising the security of your smart contracts.

Vulnerabilities Associated With Floating Solidity Pragma

Backward Incompatibility: Newer compiler versions might introduce breaking changes or deprecate certain features, which could cause your existing code to behave differently or become invalid when compiled with a newer compiler version. This can lead to unexpected behavior or vulnerabilities in your smart contracts.

Unintentional Adoption of Experimental Features: Newer compiler versions may introduce experimental features or changes in language semantics. By floating the pragma, developers may unintentionally adopt these features, which could have security implications if they are not fully understood or properly vetted.

Security Patch Delays: While newer compiler versions may include security patches and improvements, relying on a floating pragma means that your code might not automatically benefit from these patches until you explicitly update the pragma directive and recompile your contracts.

Link to the article